Workflow - Transition from Simulation to Animation

Hello,

I’m new to Ragdoll. I have a question about how to approach a specific shot and a general question about how to use Ragdoll simulation as a guide for animation and how to approach transitioning between the two.

Specific Shot Case

Shot Brief

  • There are two characters, charA and charB.
  • charA is free falling.
  • charB catches charA in his arms.

Using the pin and attach constraints, I made a setup that technically works but with two main problems:

  1. charA needs to grab charB and try to hold on but since he’s simulated, he dangles like a corpse. He needs to perform during the simulation.
  2. charA’s resting pose, determined by the simulated collision between the two characters is not appealing.
  • How would you approach this shot?
  • How would you add performance to charA during the catch?
  • How would you address unappealing poses that arise from a settled collision between two dynamic characters?

General Workflow

I’d love to know how to transition from simulation to animation where the new animated start pose is determined by the simulation.

For example, imagine this shot brief for a single character:

  1. Walks (Animation)
  2. Falls to the ground (Simulation)
  3. Crawls along the ground (Animation)
  4. Falls through a trap door (Simulation)
  • How would approach Step 2 to make the character use its arms to help absorb the impact?
  • How would approach Step 4 to make it reach to hold on to the edge while falling?

I’ve read these threads:

A fluid blend form kinematic to ragdoll
Animating reaction to blow over existing keyframe animation

There’s some great info there.

I’d love to use ragdoll more. Any guidance would be really appreciated.

Versions

Maya 2023.3.5-53.0
Ragdoll 2023.04.09

Hi @Grae, welcome to the forum! :partying_face:

Would it be possible to see what you have come up with so far? If not the originals, something you can reproduce with home-made assets (like just a box) to illustrate where you find the challenge begins?

Thanks for your reply, @marcus. :smile:

Unfortunately, my ragdoll license is tied to the studio where I work so I can’t upload any media.

My question is really about the approach or the strategy. Once the motion is driven by physics, how would you add performance to a simulation?

For example, imagine a character is tumbling down a hill. You can drive that movement with physics. But, if the character is also trying to stop themselves from falling, (use their limbs for balance, to absorb impacts, hold on to the ground, etc.) how would you approach that type of hybrid situation?

Thanks,
Grae

As a general strategy to a general question, the answer is quite close to this other answer here:

In a nutshell, you use animation to steer the simulation. You control how much influence to give your animation - from 100% by setting Markers to “Animated” to 0% by setting Rotate Stiffness to 0. You control whether you want local influence - e.g. maintain a pose while tumbling down that hill using Rotate Stiffness on each Marker - or global control e.g. “Reach this position and orientation in worldspace” using Pin Constraints.

If you can’t provide examples of your work, then samples of either animated or real-world footage from e.g. YouTube of what you’d like to achieve could also help spark the conversation. You could use the Web version of Ragdoll to whip something together and record your screen, for the sake of conversation. General advice is generally less useful than specific advice.

1 Like